“Must
Read” Reviews
(Ed. note:
The following two articles were chosen as must reads by members
of our student body. The Kahn article is timely as it will lead
to new discussions about disease surveillance systems prompted
by the Pandemic and All-Hazards Preparedness Act (S. 3678). Hopefully
that important piece of legislation will force the CDC to adopt
a surveillance system that - in addition to real time clinician
driven data from EMS, school nurses and primary care providers,
will also include real time clinician ( DVM, Animal Control)
reporting of zoonotic diseases.
The Congressional
Research Service report on the public health and medical response
to the 2005 hurricanes should also be on the must read list of
the preparedness community. It should be noted that this report
may have underestimated the acute medical problems that arose
in the immediate aftermath of the storm. Anecdotally, it appears
that there were outbreaks of diarrheal diseases and skin lesions
at the shelters and emergency treatment shelters that were never
formally reported, in part because no good system of syndromic
surveillance was in place.)
Book/article
reviews
Confronting
Zoonoses, Linking Human and Veterinary Medicine
Emerging Infectious Diseases; April 2006
Laura H. Kahn
Review provided
by Mark Kennedy
In this article,
Kahn establishes that many of the emerging infectious diseases
(including bio-terrorist agents) encountered today are zoonoses
and can therefore be transmitted from wild or domestic animals
to humans.
She argues
that strategies for recognizing and dealing with these diseases
are deficient in that they do not provide a uniform, systematic
approach to this problem. Because of this, Kahn suggests
three strategies be adopted which would enhance our ability to
prevent and/or control emerging infectious diseases. These
strategies are
- Individual
Health Collaborations – Representing Physician
/ Veterinary collaborations at the clinical level.
- Population
Health Collaborations – Adopting a comprehensive
surveillance / reporting system involving both animal and
human health care systems in order to give both disciplines
a more complete picture of emerging threats.
- Comparative
Medicine Collaborations – Collaborative research
involving the veterinary and human medical communities which
would enhance our understanding of the relationship between
animal and human disease and improve prevention and control
strategies.
The strategies
proposed in this article represent a more systematic approach
to dealing with diseases that constantly evolve, emerging in
newer and deadlier forms. Kahn believes that it is only
logical that we adopt methods designed to provide us with the
fastest way of recognizing, tracking and treating diseases in
order to prevent the types of pandemics which we have seen historically,
and she maintains that the veterinary community plays a major
role in this.
Kahn argues
that we can no longer afford to separate the two disciplines. The
emergence of the threat of global terrorism using biological
agents and the threat of new pandemics such as avian influenza
makes the need for a uniform collaborative effort all the more
compelling.
CRS Report
for Congress
Received through the CRS Web
Order Code RL33096
Review by Janice Riedisser
2005 Gulf Coast
Hurricanes: The Public Health and Medical ResponseThe
Congressional Research Service Report for Congress entitled 2005
Gulf Coast Hurricanes: The Public Health and Medical Response
written by Sarah H. Lister (January 2006) reviews the federal
response to one of the worst hurricane seasons on record. This
report directed by Congress highlights the federal government’s
responsibilities and lines of authority relating to disaster
assistance to states damaged by Hurricane Katrina and others.
It identified
the response to Hurricane Katrina by the various federal agencies,
highlighting some of the problems encountered during those responses
. The problems ranged from logistical support issues to
the inability to continue care because of lost medical records.
Among the issues identified was the inability to use medical
personnel who voluntarily came to the affected areas because
their credentials could not be verified. The use of Disaster
Medical Assistance Teams and problems encountered by the teams
were discussed.
This report
is imperative for those responsible for planning, assessment,
or response to any type of disaster. The lessons learned from
Hurricanes Katrina and Rita highlight issues that need to be
addressed ahead of time in the planning stages, not in the response
or recovery stages.
Back
to Newsletter
|